Canada's new cruise ship rules don't fix major pollution sources, critics say
The federal government says some new cruise ship pollution measures are now mandatory, but environmental groups say the move still doesn't plug gaps that permit the ongoing contamination of some of Canada's most sensitive coastlines.
Minister of Transport Omar Alghabra announced Friday that voluntary measures established last April on the discharge and treatment guidelines for sewage (black water) and grey water - which includes kitchen water, laundry detergent, cleaning products, food waste, cooking oils and grease as well as hazardous carcinogens and other pollutants - will be mandatory immediately under an interim order.
But the largest source of acidic waste water from cruise ships and other vessels will continue to flow into the ocean unabated, said Anna Barford, shipping campaigner for Stand.earth Canada.
While the grey water and sewage rules were expected in the spring before the cruise season got underway, they are a welcome step to improve the sector's impacts on marine ecosystems, Barford said.
However, it leaves out more than 90 per cent of cruise ships' polluted discharge from onboard scrubber systems – exhaust-cleaning systems that use water to “wash” pollutants such as sulphur dioxide, carcinogens and heavy metals from exhaust and then flush them into the ocean rather than the air.
The new rules also have no dedicated onboard observers to ensure cruise ships follow the new sewage and grey water rules, Barford said.
“We know from the experience of our U.S. neighbours it's necessary to enforce and catch the rule breakers,” she added.
The new regulations prohibit cruise ships from dumping grey water or sewage within three nautical miles of shore.
And the rules also call for better treatment for grey water discharge by requiring cruise ships to use a marine sanitation device in order to dump grey water within 12 nautical miles of shore.
Vessels must report they are complying with the measures on request, and if found to be breaking the rules during inspection, which take place at port, they face a potential maximum penalty of $250,000, said Transport Canada.
The new sewage and grey water regulations are now in line with the more stringent rules already in place in Canada's Arctic and other comparable waters along the West Coast like Alaska, California and Washington state, Transport Canada added.
But the ministry was silent about the fact it's OK for cruise vessels to dump scrubber wastewater along the length of B.C.'s inland coast, as well as in federal marine protected areas and the Arctic Ocean, a particularly sensitive marine ecosystem facing dramatic increases in shipping as the sea ice melts with climate change, Barford noted.
The ministry did not clarify if or when it plans to take action to ban or restrict polluted scrubber wash water - something numerous jurisdictions, including California and European countries like Germany and France, have already done, she added.
Polluted scrubber water could be completely avoided if ships were mandated to use cleaner-burning fuels to meet the International Maritime Organization's (IMO) emission standards.
But the IMO and Canada's rules allow ships to use dirty heavy fuel oil (HFO) if they also use scrubber systems.
Both Transport Canada and the IMO should prohibit scrubbers that enable all vessels to continue using cheaper, more polluted fossil fuels, despite shipping's growing emissions footprint and the urgency to shift low- or zero-emission fuels, Barford said.
“They've taken an air pollution problem and turned it into a water pollution problem,” she said.
“They don't even solve all the air pollution problems,” she added, noting the scrubber systems don't deal with black carbon, or soot, that speeds up melting when it lands on snow in the Arctic.
Scrubber discharge worsens ocean acidification, which limits the ability of marine creatures like oysters, clams, prawns and crabs to form shells, especially in the early stages of their life. And heavy metals and toxins from the wastewater can build up in the food chain, threatening the health and reproduction of marine animals, especially larger ones like endangered resident killer whales.
Although cargo vessels and other boats use HFO and scrubber systems, cruise ships create exponentially more pollution because of where and how they travel, Barford noted.
“Cruise ships linger in these sensitive inshore areas along the coast and have a very high energy demand,” she said.
“So they go through a lot more fuel and create much more discharge than a ship that isn't operating a hotel onboard.”
The IMO is meeting this week to try to devise new shipping emission standards in an effort to limit global warming, Barford noted.
It's not clear banning scrubbers to eliminate HFO use is on the IMO negotiating table - but if it isn't, it should be, she added, noting it'd force the cruise and shipping sectors to transition to cleaner or alternative fuels.
“Look at jurisdictions that have banned scrubbers like California,” she said.
“They're acquiring more refined fuels, they're preparing for renewables and zero-emissions fuels by eliminating HFO, the worst one available.”
Transport Canada's did not provide answers to Canada's National Observer's questions potential federal scrubber discharge regulations before publishing deadline.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Trudeau and Harris? Poilievre and Trump? Here's who Canadians think would work best with: survey
As Americans prepare to elect their next president on Tuesday, new data from the Angus Reid Institute suggests Canadians hold differing views as to which federal party leaders would be best suited to deal with either Donald Trump or Kamala Harris.
B.C. port employers launch lockout at terminals in labour dispute with workers
Employers at British Columbia ports say they are going ahead with locking out more than 700 foremen across the province after strike activities from union members began.
Months after VRBO booking, Taylor Swift fan told home 'not available' during Vancouver concert
A frustrated Taylor Swift fan is speaking out after being pushed from a short-term rental she booked for the upcoming Vancouver leg of the superstar’s Eras Tour.
Felonies, assassination attempts and a last-minute change on the ticket leads voters to Tuesday's U.S. election
A campaign that has careened through a felony trial, incumbent being pushed off the ticket and assassination attempts comes down to Election Day on Tuesday.
Measles cases in New Brunswick more than double in three days
A measles outbreak declared in New Brunswick’s Zone 3 last week, which includes Fredericton and the upper Saint John River Valley, has more than doubled since last week.
Prison sentences handed down for sexually abusive London, Ont. parents
In handing down the sentences for two London parents, Justice Thomas Heeney told the court, "The facts of this case were the most egregious that I have encountered during my 26 years on the bench."
She was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes about a year ago. Here's how her condition was reversed
A year ago, Lorraine O'Quinn was coping with stress, chronic illness and Type 2 diabetes. Then she discovered a health program that she says changed her life.
Surprise swing state? Iowa poll has Harris suddenly leading
Based on victories in the past two elections and polls leading up to Tuesday’s election, Donald Trump had seemed almost certain to win Iowa, but a new poll has Kamala Harris with a sudden three-point lead.
Russia suspected of sending incendiary devices on US- and Canada-bound planes, Wall Street Journal reports
Incendiary devices that ignited in Germany and the United Kingdom in July were part of a covert Russian operation that aimed to start fires aboard cargo and passenger flights heading to the U.S. and Canada, the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported Monday, citing Western security officials.