B.C. mom loses appeal arguing Indigenous smudging ceremony infringed on children's religious freedom
A Vancouver Island mother who argued that an Indigenous smudging ceremony and prayer demonstration at her children's school violated their religious freedoms has been ordered to pay the court costs incurred by the school district after losing her appeal in the case.
The B.C. Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal brought by Candice Servatius, an evangelical Protestant, whose claim against the Port Alberni school district was struck down by the B.C. Supreme Court in 2020.
Appeal Court Justice Susan Griffin on Monday upheld the prior court's ruling that Servatius failed to establish that a smudging demonstration and a prayer performed by a hoop dancer interfered with her children's ability to act in accordance with their religious beliefs.
The controversy arose at John Howitt Elementary School in Port Alberni, B.C., where Servatius alleged her children were "compelled to participate" in "religious ceremonies" against "their conscientious and religious beliefs," according to the judge's decision published Monday.
The events in question, which occurred in 2015 and 2016, were demonstrations of local Indigenous culture and not expressions of the school district's beliefs or religious favouritism, the B.C. Supreme Court judge had ruled.
"After considering all of the evidence, the judge concluded that mere presence at the smudging demonstration and the prayer by the hoop dancer did not interfere with Ms. Servatius’s religious beliefs but, rather, were efforts to teach children about Indigenous beliefs," the appellate judge found.
The elementary school is within the traditional Nuu-chah-nulth territories, and approximately one-third of the students within the school district are Indigenous, according to the court.
"It is uncontroversial that public educational institutions need to be involved in reconciliation," the Appeal Court judge wrote.
"Significant efforts have been made to redress the historic legacy of schools being an unsafe place for Indigenous children and to help create better outcomes for Indigenous students."
In response to the judge's decision, Nuu-chah-nulth Tribal Council president Judith Sayers said Monday she was "very pleased that the court ruled that Ms. Servatius cannot impose her own beliefs on what an Indigenous person is experiencing when a demonstration occurs."
While satisfied with the decision, Sayers said the tribal council was "deeply disappointed" the issue was carried all the way to the province's highest court before it was resolved.
"This just shows the challenges we still have to overcome in presenting our worldviews and way of life," Sayers said. "It should not have gone to these lengths for tolerance and understanding in the education system."
MOM ORDERED TO PAY COURT COSTS
After dismissing the mother's case in January 2020, the Supreme Court judge ordered both Servatius and the school district to pay their own costs.
But the Appeal Court judge set aside that decision and instead allowed a cross appeal from the school district after it was revealed that the mother's case was being funded by the Calgary-based Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF).
"In her post-appeal written costs submission, Ms. Servatius disclosed, for the first time, that the JCCF was funding her fees and disbursements in the litigation, as well as agreeing to help her pay any award of costs by agreeing to fundraise for her if costs were awarded against her," Griffin wrote.
"Although vaguely described, there is no reason to believe that the JCCF, a frequent litigant, does not have the resources to make good on its promise and so this was in effect an agreement by the JCCF to use its resources to indemnify Ms. Servatius for any award of costs against her."
The judge ordered Servatius to pay the school district's costs for both the Supreme Court and Appeal Court hearings.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Here's where Canadians are living abroad: report
A recent report sheds light on Canadians living abroad--estimated at around four million people in 2016—and the public policies that impact them.
'We are declaring our readiness': No decision made yet as Poland declares it's ready to host nuclear weapons
Polish President Andrzej Duda says while no decision has been made around whether Poland will host nuclear weapons as part of an expansion of the NATO alliance’s nuclear sharing program, his country is willing and prepared to do so.
Harvey Weinstein hospitalized after return to New York from upstate prison
Harvey Weinstein’s lawyer said Saturday that the onetime movie mogul has been hospitalized for a battery of tests after his return to New York City following an appeals court ruling nullifying his 2020 rape conviction.
Deadly six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 sparked by road rage incident
One person was killed in a six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 in Innisfil Friday evening.
Invasive and toxic hammerhead worms make themselves at home in Ontario
Ontario is now home to an invasive and toxic worm species that can grow up to three feet long and can be dangerous to small animals and pets.
Central Alberta queer groups react to request from Red Deer-South to reinstate Jennifer Johnson to UCP caucus
A number of LGBQT+2s groups in Central Alberta are pushing back against a request from the Red Deer South UCP constituency to reinstate MLA Jennifer Johnson into the UCP caucus.
Opinion I just don't get Taylor Swift
It's one thing to say you like Taylor Swift and her music, but don't blame CNN's AJ Willingham's when she says she just 'doesn't get' the global phenomenon.
Sophie Gregoire Trudeau on navigating post-political life, co-parenting and freedom
Sophie Gregoire Trudeau says there is 'still so much love' between her and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, as they navigate their post-separation relationship co-parenting their three children.
First court appearance for boy and girl charged in death of Halifax 16-year-old
A girl and a boy, both 14 years old, made their first appearance today in a Halifax courtroom, where they each face a second-degree murder charge in the stabbing death of a 16-year-old high school student.