B.C. woman acquitted of failing to provide breath sample because police did not make demand 'immediately'
A B.C. judge has acquitted a Vancouver Island woman of failing to provide a breath sample because police waited several minutes before asking her to blow into an alcohol-screening device after they suspected she was impaired.
The judge also found "obvious inconsistencies in the police evidence" in the case prior to ruling the officers' delay in demanding the breath sample meant the woman was no longer legally obliged to provide it.
In a decision handed down last week, provincial court judge Ted Gouge acquitted Joanna Brooker, of Duncan, B.C., of failing to provide a breath sample because the Criminal Code requires such a demand be made "immediately" after police have sufficient evidence to suspect someone was driving while impaired.
The judge tossed out the charge when he found that upwards of 10 minutes had passed between when the officers had sufficient grounds to demand a breath sample and when the demand was actually made.
REPORT OF AN IMPAIRED DRIVER
According to the decision, RCMP Const. Mongraw was on patrol near Chemainus, B.C., on Jan. 8, 2020 when the radio dispatcher informed her of an incident at a nearby pub.
Staff at the pub had reportedly refused to serve alcohol to a woman because she appeared intoxicated. The woman allegedly got back in her car and drove away, but not before someone took down her description and licence plate number.
The dispatcher provided the vehicle's registered address to Mongraw, who drove to the home and found the vehicle in the driveway with its interior lights still on, she testified.
The officer knocked on the front door and was answered by Brooker and a man who were arguing, she said. The woman had red, glassy eyes and a strong smell of alcohol on her breath, she said.
Another police officer, RCMP Const. Wreggitt, testified that he arrived at the home and found Mongraw speaking with the man and Brooker, with whom he had previous dealings.
Wreggitt also observed that Brooker had red, glassy eyes and smelled strongly of alcohol, according to his submissions to the court.
CONFLICTING REPORTS
When Brooker told the police she was unwilling to speak with them further and was going back into the home, Wreggitt told her she was being detained for an impaired driving investigation and the two officers escorted her into the backseat of Wreggitt's police car.
Mongraw then went back to the door and spoke with the man, who told her Brooker came home intoxicated, according to the officer's testimony. Mongraw estimated the conversation lasted nine minutes.
However, the man testified in Brooker's defence and denied telling police Brooker was intoxicated when she got home. He instead testified that Brooker was drinking vodka at the house before he got home and he did not know whether or not she was sober when she arrived home.
When Mongraw asked Brooker for a breath sample, she refused and asked to speak with a lawyer, according to the police testimony. Mongraw then told her she was under arrest for refusing to provide the sample.
'I AM OBLIGED TO ACQUIT HER'
The judge ruled that Mongraw had reasonable grounds to demand a breath sample as soon as she spoke to Brooker at the front door, given that she had the report from the pub, including a description of the woman and the vehicle, and could smell alcohol on the woman's breath.
"Those facts were sufficient to entitle Const. Mongraw to make a breath demand," the judge wrote.
Because Mongraw did not have access to an alcohol-screening device until Wreggitt arrived with one, the demand for a breath sample "should have been made as soon as Const. Wreggitt arrived," the judge found.
Instead, the estimated nine or 10 minutes that passed while Brooker waited in the police vehicle before the demand for a breath test was given was more than was reasonably necessary, the judge found.
"I conclude that the demand in this case was not made 'immediately,' and that Ms. Brooker was not legally obliged to comply with it," the judge wrote. "For that reason, I am obliged to acquit her."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
They were from different countries and barely spoke each other's languages. More than 20 years later, they're still happily in love
He decided to spend Christmas somewhere that wouldn't involve snowstorm disasters. She was spending the holidays with family, travelling for the first time outside of her native country of Venezuela. 23 years later, they're still in love.
Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say
A man who doused himself in an accelerant and set himself on fire outside the courthouse where former U.S. President Donald Trump is on trial has died, police said.
12 students and teacher killed in Columbine school shooting remembered at 25th anniversary vigil
Thirteen victims of the Columbine High School shooting were remembered during a vigil Friday on the eve of the 25th anniversary of the shooting that was the worst the nation had seen at the time.
Young people 'tortured' if stolen vehicle operations fail, Montreal police tell MPs
One day after a Montreal police officer fired gunshots at a suspect in a stolen vehicle, senior officers were telling parliamentarians that organized crime groups are recruiting people as young as 15 in the city to steal cars so that they can be shipped overseas.
Israeli airstrike in southern Gaza city of Rafah kills at least 9 Palestinians, including 6 children
An Israeli airstrike on a house in Gaza's southernmost city killed at least nine people, six of them children, hospital authorities said Saturday, as Israel pursued its nearly seven-month offensive in the besieged Palestinian territory.
Mandisa, Grammy award-winning 'American Idol' alum, dead at 47
Soulful gospel artist Mandisa, a Grammy-winning singer who got her start as a contestant on 'American Idol' in 2006, has died, according to a statement on her verified social media. She was 47.
Iraq investigates a blast at a base of Iran-allied militias that killed 1. U.S. denies involvement
Iraqi authorities said Saturday that they were investigating an explosion that struck a base belonging to the Popular Mobilization Forces, a coalition of Iran-allied militias, killing one person and injuring eight.
The House is on the brink of approving aid for Ukraine and Israel after months of struggle
The House is preparing in a rare Saturday session to approve US$95 billion in foreign aid for Ukraine, Israel and other U.S. allies.
'It was joy': Trapped B.C. orca calf eats seal meat, putting rescue on hold
A rescue operation for an orca calf trapped in a remote tidal lagoon off Vancouver Island has been put on hold after it started eating seal meat thrown in the water for what is believed to be the first time.