B.C. judge dismisses realtor's claim dealership misled him about Ford Mustang
A Vancouver Island real estate agent has lost his bid to recover a deposit he made on a new Ford Mustang that he intended to offer as a prize in a year-long contest in 2020.
Duncan provincial court judge J.P. MacCarthy dismissed the claim brought by Peter Andrew Sterczyk against DFS Motors Ltd., which operates as Island Ford.
According to MacCarthy's June 21 decision, Sterczyk conceived of the contest – which he dubbed "Win My Ride" – in 2019. The idea was to promote his business by entering anyone who completed a real estate transaction with him into a draw, which would give them a chance to win his vehicle as the prize.
"His plan was to acquire a new car with dealer financing in December 2019, use it during 2020 and then draw the winner on Dec. 31, 2020, pay off the financing balance owing and transfer title to the winner in January 2021," MacCarthy's decision reads.
Sterczyk reached out to Island Ford because it was offering its own promotion at the time, called "Mustangs at Cost," which promised deep discounts on new Ford Mustangs.
The real estate agent contacted Island Ford salesperson Abraham Lee, who eventually sent him a window sticker for a vehicle at another dealership in the Lower Mainland, which Lee proposed to acquire for Sterczyk to purchase, according to the decision.
Based on the window sticker, Lee and Sterczyk agreed on an offer to purchase, and Sterczyk made a $2,500 deposit by credit card, MacCarthy's decision reads.
Though Lee did not tell Sterczyk which dealership the vehicle would be coming from, the window sticker included the Vehicle Identification Number, which allowed Sterczyk to look up the vehicle and find it advertised on the website of Mainland Ford in Surrey.
Sterczyk noticed that the vehicle listed on the website had more features than the window sticker listed, something MacCarthy concludes in his decision that neither Lee "nor any other representative" of Island Ford knew at the time Lee accepted Sterczyk's deposit.
As a result of the upgrades that had been made to the vehicle at Mainland Ford, Lee informed Sterczyk that it was no longer available at the $30,000 price point that had been agreed upon, and began looking for alternative vehicles, according to the court decision.
Sterczyk rejected three other vehicles with fewer features, arguing that the agreement he made was to purchase the specific vehicle with the VIN identified on the original window sticker.
Eventually, he took Island Ford to court over the issue.
Sterczyk's claim sought the return of his deposit, as well as damages for the alleged breach of contract, which his lawyer described in a demand letter to Island Ford as a "bait and switch."
After summarizing Sterczyk's argument that he thought he was entitled to purchase the specific Mustang with its unexpected upgrades at the agreed-upon price, MacCarthy rejected it.
"With the greatest of respect, I find that such reasoning has no merit," he writes in his decision.
"I am quite certain that the Claimant would not be adopting that reasoning (and rightly so) if it turned out to be that the features and accessories described in the vehicle’s original window sticker had actually been removed from the vehicle or were of lesser quality or fewer in number."
"In other words, on the basis of this faulty reasoning, although the vehicle being purchased by claimant would be of lesser quality or value than described in the vehicle’s original window sticker, the VIN would be entirely decisive of the subject matter of the negotiations or any resulting contract. In my view, the parties did not reach such an agreement."
Instead, the judge concluded, the agreement the parties reached involved the purchase of a "stock" Mustang for $30,000. Thus, the dealership's efforts to find a suitable replacement vehicle constituted a fulfillment of its obligations under the contract, rather than a "bait and switch" or other deceptive sales tactic.
"It was the claimant who wrongly and unreasonably rejected those alternative Mustangs and caused the breach," MacCarthy writes.
The judge dismissed Sterczyk's claim in its entirety and awarded some court costs to Island Ford.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Ottawa public school board, 3 Toronto-area school boards launch lawsuit against social media giants
The Ottawa-Carleton District School Board and three school boards in the Toronto-area have launched legal action against social media giants, accusing them of "disrupting students' fundamental right to education."
Several flight attendants from Pakistan have gone missing after landing in Canada
Multiple flight attendants from Pakistan International Airlines have abandoned their jobs and are believed to have sought asylum in Canada in the past year and a half, a spokesperson for the government-owned airline says.
Tipping is off the table at this Toronto restaurant
A Toronto restaurant introduced a surprising new rule that reduced the cost of a meal and raised the salaries of staff.
Rainfall warnings of up to 90 mm among weather alerts in effect for 7 provinces
Rainfall warnings of up to 90 millimetres, air quality advisories and other alerts have been issued for seven Canadian provinces, according to the latest forecasts.
King Charles calls for acts of friendship in first public remarks since Kate's cancer diagnosis
King Charles III gave public remarks for Maundy Thursday, addressing the importance of acts of friendship, following his and Catherine, Princess of Wales’ cancer diagnoses.
A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
A Nigerian woman who wrote an online review of a can of tomato puree is facing imprisonment after its manufacturer accused her of making a “malicious allegation” that damaged its business.
Ukrainian child asylum seekers in St. John’s get class of their own
Roughly 50 children will gathered in a St. John’s classroom for the first time on Saturday for unique lessons on Ukrainian language, culture and history.
Donald Trump assails judge and his daughter after gag order in N.Y. hush-money criminal case
Donald Trump lashed out Wednesday at the New York judge who put him under a gag order that bars him from commenting publicly about witnesses, prosecutors, court staff and jurors in his upcoming hush-money criminal trial.
A fight to protect the dignity of Michelangelo's David raises questions about freedom of expression
Michelangelo's David has been a towering figure in Italian culture since its completion in 1504. But in the current era of the quick buck, curators worry the marble statue's religious and political significance is being diminished.